Nonprofit or informal project: choosing a structure
You do not need to form a nonprofit to start doing good work, but some goals, such as accepting tax-deductible gifts or applying for many grants, depend on structure. This guide compares the common paths and points to primary sources.
What this guide covers, and what it does not
This guide is general education, not legal, tax, or accounting advice. Rules differ by country, state, and city, and by the structure you choose.
References below are to U.S. federal sources because they are the most widely requested. If you are outside the United States, or your project is regulated differently where you live, use your own government's equivalent sources. Nothing here recommends a structure for your situation.
Three common paths
Most early projects start in one of three ways. Each is legitimate, and a project can move from one to another as it grows.
- Informal group: a few people working together without a separate legal entity. It is the fastest way to start, but the group itself generally has no tax-exempt status, and personal responsibility can be unclear.
- Under an existing organization: an established nonprofit agrees, in writing, to host or sponsor your project. Terms vary widely, so the agreement matters more than the label. It is often called fiscal sponsorship.
- Your own organization: you form a legal entity under the laws where you are, and, if you wish and qualify, ask for tax-exempt recognition. This gives you independence and more responsibility.
Questions that usually decide it
You can often settle the choice with honest answers to a handful of questions.
- Will you accept money from the public or from grant makers, and will they ask for proof of tax-exempt status?
- Do you plan to hold money, sign contracts, rent space, or hire people in the project’s own name?
- Does an existing organization already share your purpose and have capacity to host you?
- How much ongoing administration, such as annual filings, board meetings, and records, can your group sustain?
- How long do you expect the project to last: one season, or many years?
State-level formation and federal tax-exempt recognition are different steps
In the United States, forming a nonprofit corporation or similar entity is done under state law. Being recognized by the IRS as exempt from federal income tax is a separate application. The IRS explains in Publication 557 that, to qualify as a charitable organization described in section 501(c)(3), an organization must be organized and operated exclusively for exempt purposes, and none of its earnings may benefit private shareholders or individuals.
Recognition is not automatic and it is not instant. The IRS describes the application steps and forms on its “Applying for tax-exempt status” page. Many organizations also need an Employer Identification Number first, which the IRS issues free of charge.
State and local requirements, including charitable solicitation registration, differ by jurisdiction. The National Association of State Charity Officials lists regulators, and a local nonprofit lawyer or legal-aid program can explain what applies to you.
Donations and deductions
Donors can generally deduct gifts only to qualified organizations, and the IRS says contributions to specific individuals are not deductible. That means an informal group should not tell supporters their gifts are tax-deductible. If a partner organization will receive gifts for you, you can check its status with the IRS Tax Exempt Organization Search and confirm the arrangement in writing.
Some income an exempt organization earns can still be taxable if it comes from a regularly carried-on business unrelated to its purpose. The IRS page on unrelated business income tax is a good place to start if you plan to sell goods or services.
A reasonable way to decide
If you are testing an idea, an informal pilot with careful records or a written agreement with a host organization is often enough. If you need independence, plan to raise significant funds, or expect the work to continue for years, speak with a qualified professional about forming your own organization. Write your decision and the reasons for it. A short note helps your future board, partners, and auditors understand how you arrived here.
Structure decision checklist
- I have written one sentence describing the purpose of the project.
- I know whether we will take money from the public or grant makers.
- I know whether we need to sign contracts or hold money in our own name.
- I have looked for an existing organization that could host or sponsor us.
- If hosted, we have a written agreement covering money, decisions, and ending the arrangement.
- I have read the IRS pages on applying for tax-exempt status and Publication 557.
- I checked partner status using the IRS Tax Exempt Organization Search.
- I have found my state charity regulator and asked about registration rules.
- We are not telling supporters their gifts are deductible unless that is confirmed.
- A lawyer or accountant licensed where we operate has reviewed our plan.
- We have written down our decision and our reasons.
Sources and further reading
Primary sources are linked so you can read the rules yourself. Laws and guidance change, and they differ by location, so check the current version where you live.
- IRS — Applying for tax-exempt status. Steps and forms for requesting federal recognition.
- IRS Publication 557, Tax-Exempt Status for Your Organization. Organizational and operational requirements, and how recognition works.
- IRS — Charitable organizations. What counts as a charitable purpose for federal purposes.
- IRS — Apply for an Employer Identification Number (EIN) online. Free application directly from the IRS.
- IRS Publication 526, Charitable Contributions. Which gifts donors may deduct, volunteer expenses, and recordkeeping.
- IRS — Tax Exempt Organization Search. Check whether a partner organization is recognized and eligible to receive deductible gifts.
- IRS — Unrelated business income tax. When some earned income of an exempt organization can be taxable.
- National Association of State Charity Officials. Directory of state charity regulators; registration and solicitation rules vary by state.